Your reasoning about Romana's post is exactly why I don't think you should delete it. Five days, IMO, is more than enough time to have worked it out one way or another.
As for the log thread, as I saw it the conclusion took two assumptions: 1) that Cho had been brainswapped at all and 2) that she's been swapped with the Doctor. I can see how the second assumption would be easy to make after the first, but what I didn't see was where the first came from. Looking back on it, it may have been more an issue with how the tag was phrased. It didn't come off like an assumption or a suspicion, but like Lance just knew right away, which made me go "well hang on a minute =|" Also the questioning whether Cho was really a "her." I couldn't see what I had done to make Cho appear to be not-a-girl. Unless it was because "her" behavior was subtly reminding Lance of the Doctor, but in that case I'd put it down as another phrasing issue.
And wow, it's been so long since I played Pokemon Silver that I forgot he was that guy. I can understand him being a prodigy in that case - maybe all I'd need to see is a little more explanation of how his process works. Since in LJRP, we do get to see the inside of his brains in a way the canon didn't let us.
I have to go afk now and I can't think of any other instances off the top of my head, but I could discuss this more later if you'd like to =)
Is okay! Have some tl;dr back.
As for the log thread, as I saw it the conclusion took two assumptions: 1) that Cho had been brainswapped at all and 2) that she's been swapped with the Doctor. I can see how the second assumption would be easy to make after the first, but what I didn't see was where the first came from. Looking back on it, it may have been more an issue with how the tag was phrased. It didn't come off like an assumption or a suspicion, but like Lance just knew right away, which made me go "well hang on a minute =|" Also the questioning whether Cho was really a "her." I couldn't see what I had done to make Cho appear to be not-a-girl. Unless it was because "her" behavior was subtly reminding Lance of the Doctor, but in that case I'd put it down as another phrasing issue.
And wow, it's been so long since I played Pokemon Silver that I forgot he was that guy. I can understand him being a prodigy in that case - maybe all I'd need to see is a little more explanation of how his process works. Since in LJRP, we do get to see the inside of his brains in a way the canon didn't let us.
I have to go afk now and I can't think of any other instances off the top of my head, but I could discuss this more later if you'd like to =)